Weird Kids
Is raising children unconventionally really bad parenting?
Not long ago I was having beers and spaetzle with a friend at a dingy Manhattan bar. We were there to commiserate about work and talk strategy for an upcoming business trip. The trip meant that once again, she would have to hand her son over to her parents for a few days. At just three years of age, he was already well-versed in the art of video chatting. When she told me this, she sighed and confessed, “I think I’m raising a weird kid.”
I’ve heard this from a lot of my friends lately. It seems like “raising a weird kid” is the new euphemism for “bad parent.” If you aren’t convinced, just look at the debate over Shiloh Pitt-Jolie’s cross-dressing. Most of the vitriol isn’t about her gender-bending sartorial preferences (although, sadly, some of it is); it’s more about whether Brangelina should allow it in the first place. Do they risk their oddball child turning into an oddball adult by letting her dress as a boy? My friends share these concerns about their own parenting. They worry, “Will the odd things I let them do ruin them for life?”
Fortunately, I’m in a position to reassure them. Each time one of my parent friends voices their weird kid/bad parent concerns to me, I trot out my own childhood, which was a complete circus. Literally.
At less than a year old, I could be found dressed in a tiny clown costume, balancing on my father’s palm as a large crowd in Baltimore’s Inner Harbor circle around. My mother collected small bills from the audience in an upside down hat. Eventually Baltimore cracked down on the city’s street performers, and my parents were forced to find another source of income. They did what any reasonable, rational parent with an abundance of circus skills would do – they bought a VW bus, researched early American folk songs, dreamed up a few new magic tricks and took to the road, kids in tow, to revive vaudeville.
From that point on, much of my youth was spent crammed into the back of the bus, traversing the east coast with my family’s travelling show. For us, learning to juggle was both a family rite of passage and a necessity. So was learning to walk a tight rope, balance on stilts and ride a unicycle (when the VW van broke down, we used the unicycles to get to school). We performed for anyone who would have us – renaissance fairs, schools, corporate picnics. We often joined forces with other performers, collaborating on stunts and pooling resources. As a result, one of my early crushes was on a young contortionist studying mime under my mother. All of this was back in the early eighties – before shows like Cirque du Soleil and America’s Got Talent brought juggling to the masses and every hippie discovered the joys of six-foot-high unicycles. And yet we weren’t total outcasts. We were just the “strange family” in a very small, conservative town – when we were in town at all.
It’s no surprise that this kind of upbringing resulted in us kids turning out, well, weird. At age 4, my brother (now an accomplished architect) once played “dog” for nearly six months. Rather than prohibit this behavior, my parents bought him a leash, which he wore everywhere. Around the same age, my sister also struggled with an early identity crisis and was fond of donning different personalities (with corresponding costumes). Her favorite alternate persona was “Jack, The Lost Little Boy” who wore cowboy boots and a western shirt and, much like Huck Finn, was always having adventures and getting into trouble. Was it odd? Definitely. But thankfully, in the highly creative world of performers in which we grew up, imagination was an asset. Our off-the-wall personalities were incorporated into the already off-the-wall show. Inspired by my brother’s performance, my parents incorporated an actual canine – Waggs upstaged us all – and my sister and I played lost little orphan characters each night.
When the show finally disbanded and my siblings and I began attending school regularly and making friends with people whose parent’s weren’t clowns, the three of us found that our ability to be weird still worked in our favor. We weren’t afraid to try out new ideas in school, and this helped in every subject, not just the obviously creative ones. We were quicker to adapt to new situations and scenarios than other kids. We knew how to play constructively. Plus, we could juggle – really, really well. Which our peers thought was fantastic.
As I tell my friends, kids are weird – even if you don’t have them video chatting before age 3 or let them cross-dress. They observe things we’ve forgotten to see through that imagination lens that gets dirtier and more obstructed as we age. They break rules and conventions in ways that make us uncomfortable because we’ve become accustomed to rules and conventions. And that’s kind of what makes kids great. The more it’s encouraged, the better. I’m not saying endanger your kids (Smoking Baby is weird too, but not in a good way). But the weird and kooky things parents subject their kids to (or allow them to do) are the life-experience equivalent of naked baby photos. Yes, they can be embarrassing (try explaining as a woman that your father’s dream for you was to be a sword swallower and see what kind of reaction you get) but it’s also the one time in their lives when being absolutely off-your-rocker-strange is going to be acceptable. Rather than leaving your kids dysfunctional and mal-adjusted, eccentric origins and behavior are more likely to make them intriguing, not to mention flexible and creative.
And I have one more defense of strangeness: all that weirdness, everything you think you’re doing wrong (and believe me, my parents thought they messed up a lot), could end up providing a bond between you and your kids and between them and their siblings. This is the stuff that will provide the bulk of the comedy at the dinner table when they grow older. I know it has for my family, and I’m sure it’s going to for the Pitt-Jolies. What makes us close is this shared history of weirdness. We laugh about it until we’re unable to speak. And for me, that “can’t speak” moment is the best proof that, weirdly, we turned out all right.








My dad was a criminal defense attorney. I grew up with drug dealers calling, prositutes being invited to Christmas dinner, and my parents knowing half of the homeless people in town by name, so it never occured to me to be afraid of them. And yet I have been worried about making my kids “weird.” Me and my sisters always LIKED that about our house. And now both my sister and I get suprised comments about how well we adjust to strange situations.
My seven year old daughter decided today to wear her black cat tail to school. It’s a furry flexible cat tail that was part of her costume for Halloween. I laughed and said it looked great. Then, in the elevator, I began to worry about school. Over-anxious I said to her that the school may ask her to take it off because they wouldn’t want kids wearing costumes to school. God love our progressive little school, when I picked her up it was still on. I asked if she’d worn it all day and she said “I took it off for PE”. I’m laughing as I write that.
Great article; I agree from experience. I’m one of the few adult autistics that had full parental support as a truly weird kid: I could run around on all fours, play an album/video endlessly, walk on my toes, whatever. I was happy and really well-liked by other kids, got great grades, honed my one strong talent enough to get into a top university and then started using it to help others. Most of that doesn’t really apply to the autistic folk (including the ones that were far less delayed/impaired) I’ve known whose parents tried to make them fit in rather than accepting them.
Thanks for making this post, by the way. I’d been hoping to participate in “Autistics Speaking Day” but had no idea what to post and didn’t want to just talk to myself on my blog. Ah, well, at least I wrote it on November 1st, even if it’s being posted a half-hour late!
I love this piece. I grew up in a resolutely normal family, but my wife and I have an outlook that is a lot more accommodating of eccentricity. What do you do when your son wants to pretend to be a dog for 6 months? Letting him do so makes a lot of sense to me, part of creative exploration of childhood. I think there is an argument that the ability to think creatively is becoming more valuable in the marketplace, and giving your kids more creative freedom than you had as a child may be a sensible adaptation to an evolving world (this is what I will tell my mother). Thanks for this.
This is a wonderful essay about embracing the weird in its myriad forms. Building a society more accepting of weirdness is a legitimate anti-bullying strategy unto itself. Unfortunately, certain weirdnesses, like boys in sparkly princess dresses, trigger more than peoples’ weirdometers–they trigger homophobia and mysogeny and their resulting violence. Even that can be combatted too, with parental acceptance. That is what struck me as so wonderful about your story–that your parents accepted and embraced all that you and your siblings had to express. And that gave you the confidence to be whoever you were going to be, once you got out into the real world of school. Enough acceptance at home and confidence on the streets and we have a world that’s more accepting all sorts of weird.
Love this! I think letting children be creative and do things ‘out of the norm’ is great. It builds their curiosity and imaginations.
I grew up fairly sheltered in a small town in Colorado and wanted to be different. I never managed more than wearing odd, unmatching clothes most of the time because that’s all I was allowed. In high school I found my best friend in the world and she and I would dress in themes on the weekends…dressing as hippies, men, rock stars, whatever we felt like. I don’t think it made me a terribly odd adult, although I do have no sense of style.
I let my 3-year-old daughter dress in whatever way she wants. She comes up with some great, colorful ensembles! She has wacky hair days, too. I want her to dream big and if I squelch the things she wants to do now, I’m squelching who she is. If it doesn’t hurt anyone, let kids be kids!
Thanks for all the positive feedback, everyone! A few things:
@Abby I love that your parents introduced prostitutes et al to your Christmas gatherings! What better way to show kids that people are people, no matter how flawed.
@Sarah Hoffman It’s true: I WAS lucky to have parents who supported who we were at our base, even if at that moment we were dogs or lost little boys or “Jessica Jagaur” (the alter ego I adopted; I tried to get my parents to change my name legally). I think you’re right — that support can make all the difference in the world.
I love, love, love this article! Knowing the author and the amazing woman that she is helps too
but the message really speaks to a lot of the hidden fears we have as parents without our handy-dandy “parenting instruction booklets.” I would also agree that the lack of cultivation of creativity in our children’s lives is undermining many of the soft skills that we seek in them as adults – personally and professionally. The ability to look outside the box, to see possibilities, to adapt to unique and ever-changing scenarios and accept people who aren’t like us — these are all things I think are becoming lost in the high-stakes world of testing. Thank you for this article Aer. I really hope my young parent friends will read this…
Aeriel,
You have always been a most wonderful young lady. I am glad you had a chance to grow up ” weird”. I think back to my sons obsession with the hot pink feather boa my daughter promptly put on him when she opened her new dress up kit. He wore it every where for days, sometimes with heels and jewelry. At the same time my daughter wanted to “be a fireman on a hook and ladder truck” just like the song in the video she watched everyday. Taking them to the store was an adventure, people would come up to me and tell me how wrong it was to let him dress like that, or actually tell my daughter she couldn’t be a fireman because she was a littl girl. She would tell them to leave her lil brother alone she let him where her clothes and that she could be whatever she wanted to be. The good old days. Now middle schoolers they are hitting the wall of conformity…thank God they didn’t give in yet ! Thank you for staying “weird”
Love the article Ariel!
I won’t go into my own sufficiently antic and unconventional childhood here, but like Rufus, I admire your parents’ tolerance of your more imaginative phases. And this was such a wonderful piece overall. Thanks, Aeriel!
I blogged about my own unconventional childhood here: http://www.babble.com/CS/blogs/homework/archive/2009/04/22/katie-allison-granju.aspx
I was told when I worked at Cedar Point by one of my bosses that there is no normal. It is just a bunch of people doing what they think is normal. One person may say that something is weird or not normal to them that someone else does but to another person what that person does makes complete sense. I am not a parent but I have been a child and I know that at times people thought I was weird. I was a quiet child and a very imaginative child. I have my problems and can be very shut away but very bright. I don’t think it makes a parent a bad parent. Some people try the best they can with what they have.
I was a weird child and knew it. Sometimes i was comfortable with it, but sometimes i wasn’t because i was conscious that i was different and what others thought of me. Now i almost always love my nonconforming self, but i have set backs.
I wish sometimes that my mother was a little more open minded, because i sensed that she wanted a more ordinary daughter. Acceptance is key and i will ensure that when i have a child i will encourage originality and individuality. The world needs this.
LOVED this, as I love any odd kid. Any chance you would draw out the whole story for us in a memoir? Cuz Jessica Jaguar sounds like a girl we need to know more about. Seriously. Those of us who dreamed of running away to join the circus as a kid beseech you.
Great article, Ariel! When my girlfriend and I found ourselves unexpectedly pregnant and scared out of our minds, your mom invited us over for grilled swordfish and gave us, in her typically effortless way, perhaps the best advice on parenting I’ve ever heard: “Just love ‘em.” She recalled that kids didn’t care about all the ‘serious’ things adults cared about, and that they loved fun and just being with you. You were and still are lucky to have a mom like that.
P.S. – We now have three wonderful kids and our 19th wedding anniversary is in April.
What a wonderful article. It is a good reminder to me. We are all so driven these days, to produce the perfect child, the perfect athlete, the perfect student, and if we don’t, we fail. Oddness is a kid is seen as a failure by the parents (“really! so-and-so has a LOT of social issues”). I had a bizarre childhood, raised by hippees in Amsterdam, but now I am a very dull professional. I am ashamed of my unconventional past, but other people are not. Once my husband mentioned I grew up on a houseboat in Amsterdam and everyone was riveted. The best thing to do is enjoy our children, weirdness and all. There is no playbook on life.
great article! thank you!
Thank you so much for writing this article. I have been stressed and worried about my daughter’s ‘adoption’ of an alter-ego/persona (and her insistence that she be called by another name and that she is another child) even though I know that it is a coping mechanism (my daughter has severe food allergies, her alter-ego/persona does not; we celebrate Hanukkah but like most of her other classmates, her alter-ego celebrates Christmas). I have been playing along but have been getting more and more concerned about school and her friends and what people will think (and my husband is growing more and more frustrated and upset as the behavior continues). I love that she is imaginative and creative (and smart!). She is also unbelievably sweet and loving. And now, after reading this article and the comments below, I feel much more comfortable with continuing to play along and less worried that I am somehow doing something wrong by supporting her! Thanks again….
I love your article. Especially since you mention the story of the lost little kid. My 5 y/o loves to pretend that she is a lost little girl that has no family and it’s all alone in the street, I must see her sitting quietly in the floor and ask: Hi little girl. What’s your name? Elsie she says. Who are you here with? Are you alone? I have no family or no where to live she responds. To which I must say: Do you want to come live with us? and take her home. She does this when we come from school or the mall, any time we are on our way back home. She also had a faze where she requested that we call her Michael Jackson, and she would not respond to any other name.
My 10 y/o is obsessed with Japanese culture and her best friend is a Chinese boy also obsessed with Japanese culture. And her 3 best friends in school have also caught the Japanese bug. Now she spends all day listening to Japanese songs and singing in Japanese. I just spent $100 buying a costume of a Vocaloid which is a Japanese animated singer. And we have Asian decorations and Chinese plates and we eat with chopsticks sometimes, and her favorite food is Ramen Noodles. Yes, I do worry sometimes that I am raising weird kids and that it’s somehow my fault. It’s nice to know that all this is probably harmless and that I’m not alone.