Is Keeping Your Name Too Inconvenient?

gail-collins-when-everything-changed-maiden-namesIf you’re like me, you probably won’t get around to reading Gail Collins’s new book for a few more months/years. Instead, you have to settle for reading all the articles about and interviews with the author of When Everything Changed: The Amazing Journey of American Women from 1960 to the Present.

Among the quick-and-easy offerings is this interview with Jezebel‘s Doree Shafrir. The two talk about the book, feminism then and now and even stuff that’s not in the book. For example: women keeping their names. Collins’s explanation of why a woman feels it’s necessary to take her husband’s name surprised me.

From Jezebel:

You didn’t have much discussion of women choosing, or not, to take their husband’s name. Among my friends this has been rather controversial—women finding out that their fiances actually feel strongly about it, for example.

Keeping your own name has dropped down again. There’s much more inclination to do it the other way. It’s never knocked me out. If you’re planning on having children, it does get kind of complicated. I changed my name when I got married because the mailman said he wouldn’t deliver the mail if I had a different name. But once you’ve created a career with a name, you’re very unlikely to want to change it. I can see how it’s important to people. I was surprised at how much it’s become unpopular again to not change, after it became such a thing that you wouldn’t do it. I do feel sorry for little kids who have these really long names.

I agree with Collins that whether or not women keep their names isn’t the biggest equality issue out there, if it’s even one at all anymore. But, based on my experience, I couldn’t disagree more with her take on different last names in the same family. It’s nothing even approaching complicated.

I say this as the mother of three kids whose last names are different from her own. Their relationship to me has never once been questioned — by insurance companies, schools, other parents. In fact, only one preschool teacher out of many has even mentioned it — unsurprisingly my last name comes up as my husband’s last name on messages and paperwork from there. But that’s it.

So, I’m wondering: is changing one’s name really “for the children” as Collins perceives it, or is there a different reason? I kept my name because (1) I like my last name (I am, conveniently, a loud talker), (2) I didn’t officially get married until after my second child was born and named, and (3) I was raised by a feminist of Collins’s generation (though my mom changed her name when she got married). The name thing was a big deal when I was growing up and there was a lot of support for the choice to not change one’s name after marriage. So, yes, keeping my name is, in part, a reflection of my upbringing — old-fashioned as it now apparently is.

Collins also mentions the long names a lot of kids have these days. By world standards, names stuffed with people of honor and each parents’ surnames still aren’t all that long. My own kids simply have a second middle name, my last name. That extra name? Not much of a bother.

(Also discussed in the interview: why there are no women hosts on late night TV. Collins says she can imagine Ellen Degeneres getting a late night gig. No! I’d prefer Amy Poehler, for what it’s worth.)

Did you keep your name or change it? Why? How’d you name the kids? (And what woman would you like to see hosting a late night talk show — hey, it’s all relevant!)

More Posts

Post-Partum Depression Predictable Even BEFORE Pregnancy

Cranky Old Guy Gives Best Parenting Advice

Pacifiers and  Bottles Lead to Speech Delays

10 Best (and Worst!) Cities for Raising Kids

Is it Fair to Call a Forced C-Section Rape?

What Pregnancy Plus Swine Flu Looks Like

The Difference Between Boys and Girls: None!

Parents! Gone! Wild!

10 Best (Most Flexible! Lowest Stress!) Jobs in the U.S.

Test Predicts PPD

Elephant Struggles to Bring Newborn to Life

10 Smartest Cities in the U.S.

Placenta Teddy Bear. So Snuggly!

Expert: Instead of Timeouts, Just Say ‘Yes’

Image: Jezebel

Article Posted 7 years Ago
share this article
facebook twitter tumblr pinterest
See Comments
what do you think?
share this article
facebook twitter tumblr pinterest
See Comments
what do you think?
what do you think?
close comments
Subscribe to the
Follow us on