Does My Blackberry Make Me a Bad Parent?
Uh, yes
I am a Luddite by nature, but I finally jumped on the BlackBerry bandwagon a few months ago. I had resisted for as long as humanly possible, but because I’m a freelancer and never home, I finally had no choice. (Editors, it turns out, don’t take the constant on-the-go of parenting as an excuse not to answer e-mail.)
I had been duly warned how this Personal Digital Assistant would change my life. “You’ll be sorry,” a friend had said, shaking his head as he checked his for the millionth time that day.
“I’ll be just fine,” I said.
Maybe, in hindsight, that was a bit too cavalier. I am fine, now, a few months in, but the transition to available-all-the-time has been a tough one for my family. It’s one we’re still navigating, and I see signs all around me that it’s tough for other families, too.
We’ve all heard stories of the accidents caused by P.D.A. use while driving, or of kids falling out of strollers while Dad sent a text, or of toddlers running or rolling into the street while Mom e-mailed her friends. Phones were one thing, but now we are walking around faces down, our eyes off our biggest prizes. Bad idea.
A New York barista told me about a couple he saw one day on a bench in front of his caf’, texting side by side while their toddler played on the little makeshift fence around a tree.
“I’m steaming milk for a drink, I look out, and the kid has tumbled off the fence into the street and is sitting there, legs raised in the air, as a car begins to back up.” He shook his head, remembering seeing the parents still totally engaged with their devices as their child nearly died.
He re-enacted his Superhero save, leaping out of the caf’ in a single bound to stop the car from running over the child. The mother, he said, finally looked up when he put the child safely down next to her.
“She just said, ‘Oh my God, thanks.’”
He laughed. “I wanted to say: remember this thing?”
Sometimes, as we parents all know, it is easy to forget “this thing” – our child. While the positives of the P.D.A. abound in theory (they free us from being chained to desks or even to any particular city, they make family time easier to schedule, etc.), real family time has definitely been encroached on by the little screens. We are present but not paying attention, alerted by a ding to every possible disaster back at the office or with a family member or friend, told by a little tinkle about every juicy bit of gossip we are anxious to hear about to save us from the drudgery of sitting at baseball practice or talking to other parents.
Signs of the backlash are well under way. Everyone from Arianna Huffington to Gretchen Rubin (author of The Happiness Project) has recommended “getting unplugged” to save relationships and lower stress levels. It’s been called a secular Sabbath, a one-day-a-week reprieve from technology, but maybe instead of just taking a day off a week, we just need to remember that face-to-face connections always trump virtual ones.
Still, as parents, we’re often forced (out of both boredom and necessity) to pay attention to things other than our children – and that’s not a bad thing necessarily. I once got in trouble at the playground for saying vehemently, “Kids don’t deserve our undivided attention!” I was making a point that babysitters being on the phone was okay because we moms did it too, that it was good for kids to be left alone, to gain a little independence and figure things out themselves. Maybe it came out wrong, but maybe the line of how much attention is too much and how little is too little is not so easy to draw. P.D.A.s are clearly not helping things.
I was reminded of this by my six-year-old a few weeks into my own BlackBerry ownership, back when I still left the ringer on.
It was a Saturday, and he and I were walking down the street, ostensibly together. I was answering a text.
My son sighed loudly with an “Uch.” I looked up, innocently.
“What?” I said.
He just shook his head. “You look at that thing more than you look at my face,” he said sadly.
I immediately put the device away and walked along with him, hand in hand, focused anew on his little gap-toothed grin and the story he was telling me about a dream he’d had, really making a concerted effort to connect. A bit later, I pulled the BlackBerry out again, only because my husband had taken both of my kids to the playground bathroom. But I got absorbed, as one does, and in the middle of texting, another text came through.
“What r u doing?” it said. It was from my husband. I looked up to see him and my children standing there, not two feet away, just watching me and shaking their heads. I started laughing. So did they. It was funny, but not. It is now our family’s cautionary tale, a reminder of what can happen if you’re not careful.








I highly recommend having a no BlackBerry zone in your house. I am one of the original “crackberry” addicts. I got my first blackberry in 2001 when I worked for a telecom company and never turned it off. As a result, I conditioned those who worked with me that I was available 24/7. When my now husband came along in 2003, we had to implement a strict no BlackBerry (or tv) rule in the bedroom. Then when our son was born in 2008, we started a no BlackBerry in the house policy except in the home office. It forces us to “turn off” our work at home, or at least manage the work better. If something is super urgent and important and needs to be addressed immediately at home, we take our BlackBerries to the home office. This way, we focus on one thing at a time – either family or work. Now my family is happy and so is my boss.
I don’t own any sort of PDA (and my cell, for emergencies only, is 6 years old). I reckon if I want to talk to you, I’ll use my regular old home ‘phone and do so. My partner on the other hand, is addicted to the ipod touch which is always within arms reach. And I cannot abide it. There is constant checking – as if there might be a facebook emergency or sudden urgent message from the guy she sat next to in math class in grade 10. It really feels like a third person has taken up residence in the middle of our marriage. I really like the idea of making ipod free zones in our house…I might just do that.
Making rules about when and where technology is allowed is a great idea! I have really been trying to be cognizant about not taking it out when my kids are around and need me, trying to remember that there is really no such thing as a facebook emergency!!
oh my goodness, yes! I don’t have a blackberry/iphone and I am getting sick of my neighbors coming outside with their kid, ignoring her, and forcing me to babysit. Pay attention to your kid!
I’ll never own one. I only have a cell phone for emergencies. Not only do I not see the point, but if you’re using one when you’re supposed to be negaging with someone face to face, you’re just plain rude.
From what I’ve seen at various coffee shop/mall play areas, open gyms, McDonald’s Playlands, parks, etc., etc., parents who want to ignore their kids will do so whether they are glued to a gadget or not.
I have an iphone and I like it. But I also “unplug” on weekends, when I’m with my baby, or when I’m socializing with real people. It’s not really that hard to just put the damned phone down for a few minutes. And this is coming from someone who loves twitter/facebook/email/blogging. Like everything else if you use it in moderation it can be just fine.
Seems we were on the same wavelength…
http://bedford.patch.com/articles/to-have-and-to-hold-one-moms-smartphone-struggle
Appreciate your honesty in putting yourself out there and sharing your struggles with this modern-age concern.
What a fantastic article. I have been faced with this more and more as my daughter has been getting older. I made the decision a few months ago to turn off all sounds but the ringer and the text. I don’t get many calls or texts so I don’t mind responding to them, but facebook, twitter and email can wait. I can’t be controlled by the CONSTANT ping ping ping from them. It was a great thing to do. And now I am actually able to watch my little baby grow.
Great post – thank you for sharing!
Thanks for putting this out there. It is great your kid has self-preservation voice! So many kids don’t tell their parents what they feel. I am glad and I am sure it is taught by you, that your kids are vocal on how they feel. Technology is an awesome way to be productive and to help us stay connected for people who are far away and for convenience, but many have used it as a anxiety reducing tool and as a disconnection device. How can we be bored when kids are talking to us, when we are walking through an incredible city like New York, when you have a brain and thoughts that go along with it. What we need more is to be in the present moment and ask ourselves..can this text conversation, impulse to look something up on the web, or call wait, be expanded and more enjoyable over coffee, on the phone while cooking, or while folding laundry, or while we fall asleep in bed with our partner? We’ve reduced our lives to artificial connections which take away the essence of human connection. A good read is The Lonely American by Jacqueline Olds, M.D. and Richard S.Schwartz, M.D. It will wake you up to more than just your use of PDAs…
Thanks for putting this out there. It is great your kid has self-preservation voice! So many kids don’t tell their parents what they feel. I am glad and I am sure it is taught by you, that your kids are vocal on how they feel. Technology is an awesome way to be productive and to help us stay connected for people who are far away and for convenience, but many have used it as a anxiety reducing tool and as a disconnection device. How can we be bored when kids are talking to us, when we are walking through an incredible city like New York, when you have a brain and thoughts that go along with it. What we need more is to be in the present moment and ask ourselves..can this text conversation, impulse to look something up on the web, or call wait, be expanded and more enjoyable over coffee, on the phone while cooking, or while folding laundry, or while we fall asleep in bed with our partner? We’ve reduced our lives to artificial connections which take away the essence of human connection. A good read is The Lonely American by Jacqueline Olds, M.D. and Richard S.Schwartz, M.D. It will wake you up to more than just your use of PDAs…