Toddler Denied Insurance For Being Too Small

ainslin-batesFirst they’re too fat – now a kid has been denied health insurance because she’s TOO SMALL. Can we ever win?

Two-year-old Aislin Bates apparently weighs twenty-two pounds, putting her in the third percentile for kids her age. So United Health Care said no way to insuring her.

But Bates isn’t sick. Her mom told the Today Show she was six pounds, six ounces at birth (full-term). “She’s just petite,” Rachel Bates explained.

She was also a picky eater, and her parents wanted to find a reason – so they sought therapy, finding out she had a minor gag reflex issue. In therapy for ten weeks, Aislin is “developing normal (sic).”

But then came Rob Bates’ job change – and the letter from United Health Care which said they would not cover Aislin because she does not meet their “height and weight standards.”

A United spokeswoman told Denver news channel 7News, “Ours are based on several medical sources, including the Centers for Disease Control, and are well within industry standards.”

Except height and weight standards like percentiles are being thrown out by a lot of medical practitioners because they’re too general. The CDC guidelines have been criticized by the World Health Organization. In light of the current childhood obesity crisis, comparing small kids to larger ones does not necessarily indicated undernourishment – it indicates the standards are off. Breastfed kids, in particular, often fall lower on the charts than formula-fed kids, and seem underfed.

And need we point out this kid is two? Kids have growth spurts. They have periods when they peck at their food and weeks when you can’t keep food in the house.

If a two-year-old has a pre-existing condition, what’s next?

Image: 7News

More by this author:

Tagged as: ,

Use a Facebook account to add a comment, subject to Facebook's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your Facebook name, profile photo and other personal information you make public on Facebook (e.g., school, work, current city, age) will appear with your comment. Learn More.