Street Walkers
Why the suburbs are overrated.
The year before my wife and I had our first child, I wrote a book that was partially a celebration of the connected city. My inspiration was Jane Jacobs’s classic, The Death And Life Of Great American Cities, and its argument for the social benefits of teeming sidewalks and public characters and dense, mixed-use development. We were living at the time in the very neighborhood that Jacobs had written about so movingly forty years before: Manhattan’s West Village. But even as I wrote my paean to Jacobs and her sidewalk symphonies, I had an occasional pang of guilt, a sense that perhaps I was romanticizing my neighborhood. I liked walking about the streets as much as the next guy, of course, but my encounters with the strangers I stumbled across in my roaming weren’t any more profound than what I remembered from prowling suburban malls as a youth. Conversations with anyone beyond the most mundane talk of the weather were limited almost entirely to cab drivers, and even those seemed increasingly rare.
Then our son was born, and all that began to change.
I first noticed it in our building’s elevators. Our son didn’t obey the golden rules of New York City elevator decorum. He didn’t stare blankly at the closed doors or the floor numbers, as though he were alone in the space. He stared directly at people. Sometimes he tried to communicate with them. In our building, there were some well-trained Manhattanites who pretended as though they weren’t being stared at, who ignored the giggles and the da-da-da’s. But most of our neighbors cracked a smile, and a little conversation ensued. Nothing epic, of course, but enough to transmit a few particles of information: names, ages, other kids. The next time we ran across each other in the elevator, or the lobby, on the grocery store, they’d call out to my son, marvel at how much he’d grown. Some days it seemed like he was on a first name basis with half the building. And he hadn’t even started talking yet.
Those connections extended all the way down the block – to the guy at the deli, the dry cleaner, the sandwich shop, even the baristas at Starbucks. I used to joke that if he ever came back as a teenager and tried to buy booze underage at the wine store down the street from us, he’d be busted immediately, because the guys there know exactly when he was born. (Not to mention how much he weighed.)
And then we had a second child, and moved to Park Slope in Brooklyn, and the web of connections thickened. We’ve made dozens of friends through casual, kid-facilitated encounters at the playground or the local coffee shop or just sitting on our stoop eating ice cream. More often than not, the kids start the conversation, but the grownups end up finishing it. When we lived in our apartment building in the West Village, on only one occasion did we step into one of our neighbors’ apartments in the five years we were there. In Brooklyn, we’ve had our neighbors over for brunch or a backyard barbecue countless times.
This isn’t to imply that our kids are unusually outgoing. Any parent who lives in the city will recognize the phenomenon immediately. Children strengthen the connective tissue of urban streets. My wife and I happen to be at the age of viral parenting: every other week, it seems, another close friend of ours is having their first kid, or a second one. And not one of those couples – a dozen or so, in the extended group – is even contemplating a move to the suburbs. We’re staying put partially because we’re not ready to give up the city ourselves, and partially because we want our kids to be exposed to the diversity and energy of the metropolis. But I think we’re staying for another reason, too, which is that we’ve come to recognize that children help create the kind of urban space we like to think we belong to: a space of connections, of links.
My book had included an extended analogy between the way that ant colonies organize themselves into robust communities and the unplanned, bottom-up way that city neighborhoods form. Ants secrete pheromones as a way of communicating with other ants that they stumble across in their meanderings; out of those multiple interactions, the broader unit of the colony takes shape. As Jacobs observed more than forty years ago, something equivalent happens in successful city neighborhoods, which rely on the chance interactions of sidewalk life to create the magic of city living. Jacobs’ vision was an implicit critique of the automobile-centric city, where the channels of communication were necessarily limited by the speed of highway traffic, where the only chance encounters were car accidents. Pedestrian-centric cities, on the other hand, broadened the channels linking people, making the city into a web of connections rather than a space of isolated units, each trapped in their own solitary vehicle.
But after we moved to Brooklyn, I started to think that maybe there was something even better than the pedestrian-centric city: the stroller-centric city. Kids made the sidewalks more lively and humane spaces, but they did something else as well: they spread the pheromones more thickly; they made connections happen between strangers who otherwise wouldn’t have reached out to one another. The addition of our children transformed our sidewalk promenades. Strangers suddenly had a reason to talk to us, and I had a reason to talk to them. Before long, we stopped being strangers.
The beautiful truth of urban parenting is that it flows against the current of traditional cliches about parenting in the suburbs: rather than pulling you into an ever-tighter circle of close friends and family, making you a prisoner of the rec room and the back yard, having a child in the city makes you more interwoven in the fabric of that exposed, public life. Children help create a city where diversity is not just a slogan, where encountering difference is not just a grad school seminar topic. Children make our shared spaces – our sidewalks and elevators, our stoops and laundromats – into places where you can finally get to know your neighbors, after trading glances for all these years. They widen the net.








You know I may have liked your article but for the general vibe of self-satisfaction. Why bash the suburbs for being overrated? Can’t you simply point out the many virtues of raising children in the city and let your argument stand on its own merits? Or, perhaps, once you realized that your city life changed after having children, you could entertain the possibility that a similar deeper connection can occur among small town neighbors too.
Is the attack mechanism a quirky affectation of a diehard New Yorker or a learned response to criticism about your housing choice? I’m not trying to be judgmental – I’m honestly curious.
This is elegantly put, and consistent with my experience of living in New York with a 22 month old. The first time we took an epic, 5 mile stroll across New York we had no fewer than 12 different people come up and say, “how old is he/she?” or “where did you get that drink holder attachment for your stroller?” or some other variation of the above. I had lived in new york for 8 years, and the only other time i had experienced this level of spontaneous friendliness was post 9/11. What this caused me to realize is that new yorkers (and no doubt all people) want to be friendly, they would like an excuse to converse, given some ice breaker, and some evidence that you are somewhat like them. The presence of children takes the edge of people — they reduce cynicism and increase interaction, no question about it. This is among the biggest windfalls of the early parenting experience.
I live in the bay area, in a fairly suburban area and I find that kids bring strangers together wherever they are. I know this from my friends experiences, and also my own. My kids aren’t even here yet, but people see my enormous pregnant belly and they talk to me, smile at me, and wish me well. I’m highly introverted and I’m finding that what I feared most about parenthood is already true. My kids will force me into a more social life. I think parenthood turns out to be like any subculture. You find you have observable things in common and it creates a connection. A very, very old woman smiled at me the other day at the grocery store when she heard me mention that I’m expecting twins. She, too, had one day, long ago, been huge with twin babies.
Also, for although suburban, my area is very diverse. There just aren’t a lot of nightclubs in walking distance.
I loved city living, but I after the birth of my daughter we found living by the beach in LA just wasn’t kid friendly enough. Moving to the suburbs seemed frightening as a concept, so we decided to experiment for six months by renting an apartment in the suburbs north of LA, about 40 miles away. Got to say, shocked by how awesome it is here. Mountains, hiking, CLEAN parks everywhere, tons upon tons of cheapcheapcheap high quality kids programs and really friendly people everywhere. Also, way less social status sizing up than back in the city. The idea that you’re imprisoned in your tiny strip of backyard is puzzling. I don’t know anyone like that here in suburbia. Everyone is either at the beach, picking fruit at local farms, meeting up at the park or farmers’ market, hiking up mini-mountains or doing nature-based science project with their kids. Granted, I haven’t worn 4 inch heels or gone to a bar in ages, but I don’t really miss it much when there is this incredible community of people to explore. I wouldn’t knock the suburbs until you’ve tried it.