Previous Post Next Post

Pregnancy

Brought to you by

Breast or Bottle, Moms are Equally Sleep Deprived

By Rebecca Odes |

The looming lack of sleep is a major source of anxiety towards the end of pregnancy.  But if you’re letting that thought guide your plans about feeding your baby, give it a rest:  A new study says that feeding method has no bearing on a new mother’s sleep deprivation situation.

Breastfeeding is often thought to make babies wake more frequently (and make moms wake more frequently as a result).  And bottlefeeding has a reputation of making babies babies sleep through the night. But recent studies have shown that breastfeeding does not equal disaster for moms’ sleep. And a new study says that the sleep discrepancies between the two feeding methods may be more myth than reality.

The study, to be published in the December issue of Pediatrics, looked at the sleep patterns of 80 moms and measured not only actual hours of sleep, but the way the moms thought they’d slept. When it comes to sleep deprivation, perception matters—a lot.

Here’s what they learned:Whether moms fed by breast or by bottle, they got equivalent measureable hours of sleep. They also had equal perceptions of how much sleep they got. The study looked at mothers of babies in the first three months of life.

They also asked moms about their level of fatigue during the day and found no difference between the two groups. There were small variations, throughout- breastfeeding mothers did indeed wake more frequently, but they also went back to sleep more quickly. Breastfeeding hormones are probably responsible for the ease in returning to sleep. Breastfeeding mothers also tend to stay in a sleepier state while breastfeeding, while bottlefeeding requires a higher state of arousal: going into the kitchen, heating water, preparing the bottle. So bottlefeeders are often more fully awake and may have a harder time getting back to sleep than breastfeeders.

The study’s authors are hoping that these results will help women make more informed decisions about infant feeding. Mothers who make the choice to bottle feed in hopes of getting more sleep could be disappointed. And doctors don’t want babies to miss out on the value of breastfeeding for a perceived benefit that doesn’t actually exist.

“Women should be told that a choice to formula feed does not necessarily equate with improved sleep,” Said the study’s co-authors, “The risks of not breastfeeding should be weighed against the cumulative lack of evidence showing any benefit of formula feeding on maternal sleep.”

The bottom line is that little babies wake up a lot, period. How you feed your baby is your choice. But ideally, it will be one based on facts, not myths!

Read more about the study here.

photo: Karin Dalziel/flickr

More on Babble

About Rebecca Odes

rebecca-odes

Rebecca Odes

Rebecca Odes is a writer, artist and mother. She was inspired to write her blog, From The Hips, during her first pregnancy when she discovered every pregnancy book she came across made her feel anxious or irritated. She lives in New York City with her husband and two children.

« Go back to Pregnancy

Use a Facebook account to add a comment, subject to Facebook's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your Facebook name, profile photo and other personal information you make public on Facebook (e.g., school, work, current city, age) will appear with your comment. Comments, together with personal information accompanying them, may be used on Babble.com and other Babble media platforms. Learn More.

0 thoughts on “Breast or Bottle, Moms are Equally Sleep Deprived

  1. Jenna says:

    I’m not buying it. I believe that the baby doesn’t sleep longer on formula, but the thing that’s fantastic about bottle feeding (whether formula or pumped milk) is that dad can get up and do it sometimes too… and that definitly equals more sleep.

  2. Lindsey says:

    I have four kids, the first was bottle-fed(formula), the other three were breastfed. In my experience I got much better sleep with the breastfed babies for the reasons given in this article-I never had to get out of bed. My babies either slept with me or in a bassinet right next to the bed. I always imagined I would breastfeeding but it was NOT easy with the first so I gave up pretty quickly, with each of the others it got easier than the last. I say that to encourage anyone having a difficult time with nursing that you have to do what works for you and your baby abs your lifestyle, but just be size something doesn’t work with one child doesn’t mean it won’t with another, keep trying! :)

  3. Lindsey says:

    Please pardon all my typos, I get less sleep now than I did when they were iffy bitties and the result is, what I call, mommy-brain. How’s that for new mom encouragement? :)

  4. Andrea Dixon says:

    I’m curious….did this study concentrate on women who were the sole undertakers of night feedings, or did it include households where a partner or gavegiver engaged in feedings, also? I have both breast and bottle fed, and I found breastfeeding to be absolutely exhausting and emotionally draining, simply because I was the only one who could feed the baby. When my husband took a three am feeding (via formula, of course) I was able to sleep for six hours straight…something that NEVER happened w/ my breastfed child. In fact, my bf child never went more than two hours w/o wanting to nurse.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.

Previous Post Next Post