Forced Sterilization? Violation of Rights or Necessary Sometimes?

One grandmother in the United Kingdom has asked the courts to sterilize her daughter through a tubal ligation during her upcoming c-section. While it sounds heartless of her mother to ask, the situation certainly does sound heartbreaking so I can sympathize with both sides of the story.

Her daughter, a 21 year old mentally disabled mother of one child already, who is in the grandmothers care, and pregnant again for the second time with a child who may certainly end up under the care of Grandma… Mrs. P (Grandma) has asked for the courts to order her provider to perform a Tubal Ligation during her c-section scheduled for later on in the year.

It is a very sticky issue for everyone involved. The daughter of Mrs. P clearly has issues preventing pregnancy, as well as caring for her children, but should a court force her into a surgical procedure that would eliminate her ability to have children at all?

Jeanne Sager from The Stir summed it up exactly how I feel:

It’s a terrifying scenario that goes against everything I, as a feminist, have been taught about women and reproductive freedom. And yet, I can’t help understanding where Mrs. P. stands. Because one of the chief reasons I support reproductive freedom is that a mother should not bring a child into this world who she can’t support.

The situation as a whole is heartbreaking for everyone involved, especially the children, but should this be someplace for legal action, and courts to get involved in?

What do you think?

photo: flickr.com/mikeporcenaluk

Tagged as: , , ,

Use a Facebook account to add a comment, subject to Facebook's Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. Your Facebook name, profile photo and other personal information you make public on Facebook (e.g., school, work, current city, age) will appear with your comment. Learn More.