Should Dads See the Birth?
To see or not to see?
In my first pregnancy, I knew I was not alone in my fear of pooping in the delivery room. I had the Internet and a bunch of women in my childbirth preparedness classes to echo my concern. In fact, in a poll I found online, 70 percent of women admitted to this same worry.
In one class I asked the teacher about it. Her answer was the same as any I’d read online: “You’ll poop, but you won’t care.”
When she saw I wasn’t comforted by her answer, she added, “Besides, the nurses and doctors have seen it all. Everyone does it.”
My concern was not for the doctors and nurses; it was for my husband. I don’t burp in front of him, and I don’t pass gas either. I spent the first six months of our relationship “taking a walk” and finding a public restroom when necessary. Now, married for four years, though I no longer take the walks, I still close the door to pee, and I never let him watch me wax my mustache or tweeze my eyebrows. (In fact, if you see him, please don’t let him know I do either of those things:)
As my first pregnancy progressed, I became more anxious that whatever went down in that delivery room would burn an image on my husband’s retina that would make it impossible for him to ever see me as a sexual being again.
But would he? I had to ask some men.
I started with Mickey, a TV writer. His response was comforting: “Honestly, I think it is one of the most awesome things I’ve ever seen.”
I moved on to James. He works for one of those humor websites, the content of which consists of men getting kicked in the testicles a lot. There’s no way he wasn’t grossed out by the birth of his son, I was sure. And he even confessed that his wife “was really worried, so she requested that I stay up near her face when she gave birth and not look down south” and that he’s “pretty squeamish” and “didn’t object.” But, as she was delivering, the doctor grabbed him and pulled him down there, saying, “Here he comes! You gotta see this!” James’ response? “I watched the whole thing in full 3-D glory. I was so emotional that the thought of being grossed out didn’t even cross my mind. I was just crying and shaking and so happy.”
But how about later? When it was time to resume the amorous life, did the memories come back? “I didn’t really associate the vagina giving birth with the vagina I have sex with,” he mused. “It was almost a different entity.”
In fact, not one of the 12 men I spoke with mentioned being grossed out; not one of them mentioned being at all turned off later when it was time to have sex. And not one of them mentioned poop.
The closest I came to the answer I had anticipated was from Robert, a magazine editor, who described labor and delivery in these terms: “It goes from being a Ron Howard movie to a David Cronenberg movie.”
So it was gross, right? “Nah,” he says. “It was pretty amazing.”
Were all these guys lying to me, or were my teacher, my friends, and the Internet correct? How could it be that you could poop in front of your husband and both recover from it?
Dr. Louann Brizendine is a neurobiologist, M.D, and the author of The Male Brain, the sequel to her bestselling first book, The Female Brain. She says that men don’t think of birth as gross because they don’t process it as gross. “The level of emotional intensity and being on the line of life and death – because it is a life and death moment and everyone in that delivery suite knows that – gets recalled through that lens. The guys wrap all those memories into having watched the woman go through the absolute torture you have to go through delivery. His level of admiration and respect for her physical courage and ability to get through that kind of physical feat that he will never have to do overpowers all the other stuff. He’s in awe.”
Then, when the couple gets back to the master bed (if they can ever get any privacy), “Sex takes over his mind, and little details like the vision of mucous, blood, poop and babies are rapidly forgotten under the sway of his libido.”
Of course I was happy to hear that, but as it turned out, I didn’t end up pooping. Thirty hours into it, I was wishing I’d had the opportunity to as I was wheeled into an operating room. The curtain hid the view from myself, but it didn’t hide the smells, the sounds. My husband sat next to me. When we heard the baby cry, I urged him to leave my side and go tend to the baby, to see how he was doing. As he walked past my body, disconnected in so many ways from the rest of me, he saw me wide open on the operating table, my organs out for evaluation.
Now he has seen my insides turned out; he cannot un-see them. And though he has never used a word like “gross,” the experience left him jarred, seeing his whole wife in parts. When we returned home from the hospital, his hands tiptoed around me, almost as though he might be afraid I had been made of paper this whole time – a kiss on the forehead, a hug around the shoulders. Now it’s almost three years later, and though I know that, to him, I am still more delicate, more human than before, he still swings me around the living room to a favorite song and hugs me very, very tight. What he saw that day was put in a file marked “Harder Times” in his head, and it hasn’t affected our lives or our intimacy. Time went on, and now when he looks at me or when we look at our son, we do not see the trauma of his birth or the fracturing his mother endured to get him here. We see only our boy.
To me, that is the most amazing part of this process. Whatever we go through in birth, we somehow stand up, brush ourselves off and continue our lives. Our children never represent what we went through on that day. And somehow, our husbands and partners don’t seem to let anything that happened then matter either. Whether it was what we said, how we cried or what they saw, our bodies were the giver of this gift. Eventually, they forget what it came wrapped in.








My biggest concern about her relationship is that she never discussed it with her husband. I think that women who are concerned about their husbands reactions to birth should attend birthing classed with them. Did your husband at least do some research himself or was that all your duty? Having a child is a wonderful time to have open discussions; actually prior ro getting pregnant is the perfect time to discuss our worries about one another; because really how else can you plan to raise a child together. I hope she really learned this lesson in life and teaches their son that we all have the same healthy bodily functions. Oh and I hate to burst your bubble but people actually pass gas in their sleep – so surprise he knows you are healthy!
This almost brought tears to my eyes. Not because I have been in your place. Yes, I was concerned about the pooping but not because of my husband, but because of the other people that were going to be present. I pee with the door closed but to me that is a totally different thing.
Finally at my labors, the books and other people were right, I did not care, mostly because I forgot about it since I did not know when it happened. The nurses never changed their sweet, gentle attitude towards me.
I asked my husband if he wanted to be in the delivery room and he gave me a look like saying “Where else will I go?” Then is when I signed him into this adventured and we have had a blast.
Beautifully written! I especially loved the last paragraph.
Loved this. Two pregnancies, births, and breastfeeding changed the way I feel about my body (for the good) and I think gave my husband a whole new level of respect for my body, too. Our oldest is 4 1/2 now and often at the end of the day my husband still whispers as we fall asleep, “thanks for the babies.”
Great article! As the father of three kids, I was present during the entire labor and birth of all three. I walked the hospital corridors for hours with my wife in her first labor, I helped deliver our son and cut his cord, and I was able to hand our third child off to my wife and also was able to cut her cord.
My wife went through all three labors 100% drug free and my heart swells just thinking about how much I respect and admire her for the courage she showed in going through three long, natural labors!
Contrary to what Dr. Louann Brizendine says, however, fathers/husbands are quite capable of coping with the “little details” of our wives’ labor by reasons other than “the sway” of our libido.
Shocking, I know, but as fathers and husbands, we do maturely handle what our wives go through for reasons other than getting her back in the sack again.
A very candid but very valuable article. Thanks for having the courage to share that with the world.
Most likely the best piece of pregnancy advice I was given… Follow the baby – because its like looking into the kitchen of your favorite restaurant once you see it you’ll never want to eat there again…
so thats exactly what I did – watched the head crown/supported my wife and followed the baby.
Great article! I’ve been grateful for c-sections that kept my children safe but felt I was missing out on regular birth. Considered doing a VBAC but was told I couldn’t. Was a little relieved when I learned I wouldn’t be pooping on the table though
Just glad to know I’m not the only one thinking about this
I love this article! I am pregnant,now,with my first,and ever since I first read that women often poop on the table,while delivering,I,too,have been concerned. I mean,who wants to do that? But yes,everyone I’ve spoken to and everything I have read have all said that you either don’t even know,or you know and you forget all about it a second later. It is reassuring to read that men don’t care,think or even remember that it happened. A really cute article,esp the last paragraph. Had me tearing up a bit.
I’ve never been pregnant but my fiancee and I want kids. I was just as worried about pooping on the table as a lot of women get, so I talked to him about it and his basically said it’s natural and won’t bother him to see it. He’s still going to be holding my hand and not look down there – not because of pooping, but because he said it would be painful to see me stretch. I’m lucky; he’s the kind of person that even though he normally thinks that stuff is hilarious, if he saw me poop during birth he’d probably just clean it up really quickly and not say anything about it. I’ve done similar for him before (I was stimulating his prostate and got a little smear of poo on him when I pulled my gloved finger out; I just wiped it up quickly and only told him what I was doing because he asked). When you love someone that much, nothing, and I mean NOTHING, they can do grosses you out.
I’ve had three babies and never pooped on the table. It’s always a joke between my husband and I, but I know he could handle whatever happens. He’s watched each birth and says it’s a gross thing when you think of it out of the moment, but he’d never trade watching his children be born. It hasn’t affected our sex life anymore than pregnancy weight or ugly stretchmarks. Then again, we go to the bathroom with the door open and I don’t leave the room to pass gas like the author. Thank goodness because I’m sure that helped my husband deal with all the yuck that comes post delivery while you bleed, heal, lose sleep, and change poopy diapers.