No Boys Allowed
I wanted a daughter, got a son
When I was pregnant with my first child, my ultrasound-technician friend was kind enough to provide some free services at 16 weeks – the earliest she felt confident we could positively identify my baby’s gender. I was not one of those mothers who harmoniously declared, “Boy or girl, I’d be happy either way.” No, sadly, I wanted one gender and one gender only. I wanted to be a mother of girls. And I couldn’t wait to find out if my baby would accommodate.
My preference was about what I knew – I was a girl, and I grew up with two sisters. I had a clear picture of what raising girls would look like. I knew what to expect, and had a few ideas of how to handle the girl-oriented stresses that I anticipated. Additionally, I liked girl stuff. Not girly-girl stuff like princesses and fairies, which I actually abhor but some of the other stereotypical girl stuff, like playing house and making crafts and learning to cook and sew. Moreover, I liked the idea of emboldening my girls to play sports and excel academically, to defy those stereotypes and embrace girl power.
And, on the other hand, I didn’t like what I perceived boy stuff to be. I hated the thought of the endless climbing and punching and destructive games where things blow up and crash, and there is just so much shooting going on. The thought of watching Hot Wheels spin around the same loop-the-loop a thousand times or trying to comprehend baseball statistics or being witness to even a single game of cops and robbers just left me feeling empty inside.
I’m not proud of feeling this way. Boys are important and adorable and wonderful, too. One particularly great one grew up to be my loving and supportive husband. But, when it came down to it, they just weren’t the kids I wanted to raise.
Is wishing for a particular sex taboo, or no? — Katie Tietje
Poll says majority of Americans prefer one gender over the other — Danielle Sullivan
So when my friend with the magic wand told me the baby in my belly was a girl, I was not only thrilled, I was relieved. The family I had pictured in my mind was one step closer to becoming real.
When my daughter was a little over a year old, I got pregnant again. I tried to say things like, “I already have a girl, so I’d be happy no matter what this baby is.” But truthfully, not much had changed. I wanted another girl.
As the pregnancy progressed, I had to face some harsh truths. I was carrying like a basketball and not a watermelon. My right breast was larger than my left. The baby’s heart rate was on the slower side. Not only did all the old wives’ tales suggest my baby was a boy, but I myself grew more and more sure of it. I declined the freebie ultrasound from my friend, opting not to find out my baby’s gender in advance. The thought of being disappointed about the baby in my belly made me kind of hate myself. What kind of a mother feels disappointed about her unborn baby? I didn’t want to battle those emotions on top of battling an aching back and a toddler who wanted to sit on my ever-shrinking lap. I figured that if I waited to find out the gender until my baby was born, then the thrill and beauty of having a newborn in my arms would trump any petty feelings I was having about gender.
As the baby’s birth became imminent, I told my midwife not to announce the baby’s gender. “I just want to hold my baby in my arms for a moment and enjoy his or her presence before knowing,” I said between contractions. In other words, “If you tell me he is a boy, I fear I might reject him.”
My midwife respected my wishes. Immediately after I pushed the baby out, I scooped up my new child and brought the warm and squishy body to my chest. In the split second it took to lift the baby, I saw his little penis. It made me laugh. I had been right.
In all honesty, I know I experienced a tinge of disappointment. There was a fleeting moment of disbelief when I thought, “Really? I have a son?” But looking at my baby’s round face, all negativity quickly vanished. Bringing a new life into the world is a glorious event. Perhaps it was the giddying effects of the oxytocin rush, but I was just so happy to have my baby out of my belly and in my arms. He was beautiful and sweet, and he fit so snugly in my arms. He was my baby, and he was perfect, penis and all.
My son is now two years old. By all accounts, he is adorable. He does not shoot guns or blow things up. He plays with the same train set his sister enjoys. He also likes the same Legos as her, as well as the dolls, tutus, play kitchen set, and baseball bat. He likes to read books, draw, climb on play equipment, and ride a scooter.
It’s possible the destructive days are yet to come, but at this point I realize I’ll be able handle bombs and guns if they should come up. I now see that the issue of my child’s gender had very little to do with my child and much more to do with me. I had closed my mind around one specific type of boy and had forgotten how complex human beings are. My son is a boy, yes, but boys come in all different shapes and sizes. This particular fellow is a genetic mix of his mother and father. He is nurtured under the influences of his sister and extended family, his community, and his peers. He is exposed to ballet and baseball, handicrafts and hand tools. He – not I – picks what excites him most, just as his sister has done for herself. I love him no matter what he enjoys because he is my child.
When I reflect back on my pregnancy and the fears I had about having a son, I cringe. I can’t even imagine my life now without him. Every child is a blessing. They teach us about ourselves and the world, things we might never have realized we were missing. My son has shown me how truly silly I was. He happens to be just as intrigued by my sewing and cooking as his sister is. Yes, he also gravitates toward trains and cars, but so what? Some of his other interests have prompted me to learn fascinating things about sharks and outer space.
Children are not pre-packaged items wrapped in blue or pink. Society constructs gender roles, and I as a parent will help my kids negotiate them. I will do my best to help my son discover who he is and what contributions he can make to the world. And when he pretends to blow things up, I’ll just tell him to be sure to clean up his mess.








great essay!
i don’t know if i would secretly prefer one gender over the other now i know i’ll probably be happy with whomever i get to meet
lovely read!
They told me my son was a girl twice. I cried for four days when I found out. (REad the ridiculous story of HOW I found out here http://saltandnectar.wordpress.com/2011/02/22/its-a-girl-or-is-it/)
I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t disappointed when I found my second baby was a boy. I still long for a girl.
I also wanted a girl, and cried for a day when the ultrasound said it was a boy. I wanted a girl because the eldest boys in my family–uncles, brother, cousins and my own father–were lazy and irresponsible men. I don’t know why. So I was beginning to suspect it must be genetics. Haha, lazy genes. So when my firstborn was declared a boy, oh wow, the fear was crushing. But my husband assured me that the baby could end up most likely like him–a wonderful, dependable man. And that laziness isn’t inherited;it’s how you raise the kids. So I am relieved and happy I have a son because we are raising him to be a man
You are not alone! I desperately wanted a girl when I first got pregnant. I convinced myself it was a girl because my best friend had a girl and we (freakishly) lead similar lives. During my 20 week visit, I was praying to hear the word “girl”. But alas, it was a boy. I felt huge disappointment; I teared up and everything. But as my pregnancy progressed, I got used to the idea and by the time I was due to deliver, I was excited!
Fast forward (a short three months)to when I get pregnant again. I again pray for a girl. At my 20 week appointment, I am informed it is a boy. Again. This time, I break down crying. I can’t help it. I am a sobbing mess as I leave the doctor’s office.
But now, I couldn’t imagine NOT having a boy. They are sweet and cuddly and silly, and I wouldn’t have it any other way.
Love this! I have two girls and am expecting my third…slightly scared it will be a boy, but this really eased my mind!
we have mostly girls on my side of the family and my husbands and we have 3 girls so i am really happy about this
We have one boy. On my side of the family it’s mostly girls. My brother has 3 girls. My sister 1 girl, 1 boy. On hubby’s side ALL have boys. My mother in law has a total of 7 grandsons. Pressure is on us to bring a girl into the world.
you sound like a real a-hole.
my friend’s aunt makes $82/hr on the laptop. She has been out of a job for 9 months but last month her check was $7251 just working on the laptop for a few hours. Read this site http://goo.gl/5kjiI
I have always found it so sad when people need to know the sex of their child before it is born. A child is a gift and you are to love and nurture no matter what the sex is. Is it really important for you to paint the room and buy all the right colours before your baby is born or is it more important to just bond with your baby to be!
I love that she says “My son has shown me how truly silly I was” because she is so right, and like with most children it takes the second one to chill and just enjoy being a parent. During my second pregnancy both grandmothers wanted to know the sex, and the pressure I felt from their comments of hoping it was a girl, and how I so needed a daughter – really all I wanted was another healthy baby – so no we didn’t find out the sex!
You should be happy you are able to have any baby at all. Some people aren’t so lucky. You are SICK and disgusting.
Lisa: Sometimes, knowing the sex of the baby can help bonding. I know for me, after a miscarriage and an ectopic pregnancy before this pregnancy, I’m looking forward to finding out the sex in a few weeks so I can refer to the baby by name or definitively as a he or a she, not just as “the baby” or “he or she” or “it.” For me, it will be one more step to believing that this pregnancy is really happening. I don’t care what the sex is, I’m just done with surprises that I can knowingly avoid for a little while. If you want a surprise, good for you and that’s your right, but please refrain from calling those that want to find out the sex silly or sad. Everyone has their own reasons for the choices they make and the things they want, and its not your place to judge.
Some of you women are ridiculous, this mother is just sharing her experience of wishing for a girl. I am pretty sure as displayed in the comments that she is not the only mother to have felt that. Give the woman a break and get off your damn mother pedestal and learn how to support other mom’s. I doubt she loves her little boy any less. I myself have 2 boys that I am extremely proud of and if either were a girl, it would be the same.
I felt the same (almost) with my third; I had one of each and kinda hoped for another boy! My boy is quiet and nurturing and loves crafts and books. My girl is hell on wheels. But I now couldn’t imagine life without my gorgeous baby girl!! And, to be honest, I WAS disappointed for a tiny second in the delivery room when they said she is a girl. And this is during an emergency c-section when both are lives were in danger. I’m ashamed because I know so many people who would love any child, and I felt selfish for having a preference. But I also realize that I am human and that’s normal, as are you.
This post is so great and honest. I needed to read it today as I just found out we are having another boy. I was hoping for another girl bc I love my sisters and was hoping for a sister for my daughter. It’s been alot to process, including being sad over a gender when I should be happy (and am happy) to have a health baby. I loved how you ended it–what a great reminder! Thanks again. And I think the people leaving rude comments anonymously are cowards and don’t get it. Everyone is different and have different struggles to get through.
It’s refreshing to read an honest piece about gender disappointment, which still seems to be a cultural taboo. I have two girls, and I will admit there was a twinge of disappointment when the ultrasound technician announced that the second one would be another girl. My husband comes from a family of all boys that ironically all happened to have girls. There was some subtle outside pressure as this would have been the “last shot” for a grandson and part of me also really wanted to experience raising a son. I am now so happy with both of my girls and couldn’t imagine things any differently, but there will always be a little part of me that wonders “what if”….and that is okay.
Come on people posting negative, the feeling of disappointment is perfectly legitimate. As long as you don’t transfer the feeling onto the kid!
Like the author, I only wanted girls. My first was a boy, and after initial disappointment, I did fine. It didn’t hurt that he was an easy, happy baby. For my second child, I hoped I would have a girl, but the ultrasound said boy. I went home and sobbed. But…5 months later, I gave birth to a girl. Turned out those 16 week ultrasounds are 90-95% accurate and well, mistakes are made. But I got it in the end as my daughter was difficult baby and toddler.
It is a taboo to want one gender more than the other, especially if you want daughters, not sons. It is good to see honest discussion about this.
It’s nice to hear someone else say it. We always planned on having two, and I wanted to have a boy and a girl, but didn’t care which order. So when our son was born, I was really hoping that the next one would be a girl. Although I have to admit that I didn’t really expect it to happen, since for generations the men in my husband’s family have produced boys. I still hoped that ours might be the one girl.
Sure enough, this baby is a boy. And I feel AWFUL that I am disappointed. Our son is wonderful, and I know this kid is going to be amazing and SO loved as well. But I can’t help grieving the loss the of the yellow curtains, the little dresses that I was planning to make for my and my best friend’s daughter (due just one month before me), and having that nice salt-and-pepper-shaker set I had hoped for.
I had a son, and raised two grandsons. They all had dolls as well as cars. They learned to cook. And a little sewing. After all I will not be around forever to do things for them. They learned all kinds of things. I think it is important for both boys and girls to be “well rounded”.
It’s refreshing to read an article about this where the mom doesn’t make her disappointment into a huge thing, to the point that it messes up her life. I’m so sick and tired of women who have “gender disappointment” who turn it into some huge drama or act like it’s a legitimate mental disorder. Yes, some disappointment is fine, but turning into something that you actually become depressed about and all is just dumb. Those are the women who need a major reality check that having a healthy baby is a 1000 times more important than their gender or sex.
lol..i already have a boy he is 6 months, very handsome and his daddy made him jr..he is so proud of him and I am too..he is as as a girl..now I am expecting another baby I am 6 w
eeks preg..in our first baby wish was granted because my husband’s family wanted a boy from a boy/son and now I am praying for a baby girl so I can have mini me..but most important is I want my baby healthy like my first baby mark jr..
Really Krista! Every child is a blessing and it should NEVER be anout gender but how about a HEALTHY baby. Your story makes me cringe, I cannot believe someone would even post such nonsense about the sex of their baby.