Buying a crib mattress is usually a last-minute afterthought. Let's be honest, it's not as glamorous as the crib's design or as high profile as the car seat - but shouldn't it be? Crib mattresses are an investment in your child's health and development, especially considering your baby will be on it for up to 70 percent of his or her first four years. And to top it off, some of those hand-me-down mattresses might not be safe.

Many longstanding baby products have been rethought and redesigned because they contain chemicals (BPA, PVC, phthalates, etc.) that are now considered dangerous. As of February 10, 2009, the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CSPIA) banned certain varieties of phthalates from crib mattresses (most notably found in standard vinyl coverings) after evidence linked them to endocrine system problems and possibly cancer. And the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) reported that phthalates could cause more damage to babies than adults because their bodies are still developing.

The following mattresses all adhere to the government's new standards, and most go above and beyond, eliminating vinyl coverings altogether. Keep in mind that some of these substitutions require spray treatments to keep them wet and stain-resistant, and other mattresses require a mattress pad to keep odor, dust mites and bacteria from creeping in over time. Use your discretion as to how "natural" you're comfortable with, but have peace of mind that the mattresses in this guide (including the runners up!) are safe choices for your little one. Some might have a higher price tag than the norm, but most have been modified with organic and/or naturally derived products so both you and your baby can sleep better at night.

BEST INNERSPRING | Sealy Select Eco-Plush Infant/Toddler Mattress


A $300 mattress seems like pocket change next to The Pebble, but – let’s face it – it’s not. In fact, it’s two times more than what you might expect to pay for a quality innerspring, so why is it worth the extra dough? It was a close competition between this Sealy and the runner-up by Colgate (both being superior quality innersprings that convert from infant to toddler), but the Sealy ultimately won for it’s exclusive partnership with Crypton Select – an all-natural Oeko-Tex Certified cover and treatment that doesn’t contain any harsh chemicals, dyes or plastics, yet makes the mattress waterproof, stain-resistant, anti-allergen and anti-dust mite. It held up exceptionally well to moisture testing while still maintaining the natural and soft-feeling organic cotton cover. The firm innerspring infant side is hypoallergenic, as is the Oeko-Tek certified latex foam toddler side. (Being Oeko-Tek certified means it passed mega testing for allergens, chemicals, pesticides, etc.) So basically you’re paying for a safer sleep without the high maintenance of typical organic materials. Plus, it’s a durable, long-lasting and reliable choice.

« Go back to Pregnancy

3 thoughts on “Best Crib Mattresses for Baby 2010

  1. Ailie says:

    Choosing a crib mattress is not an easy task. Consider cost, comfort, and durability, as your child will probably sleep in his crib for up to three years.

  2. Tierney says:

    This mattress is amazing. We’ve had it for our son for almost a year. I wanted a mattress without toxic flame retardants and this one is perfect. Non-toxic, durable, comfortable, and stylish!

  3. Jack says:

    These mattresses are awesome. They all are eco-friendly and affordable. You have good designs and color.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *.