Dispatch: Toddler Calling
Whats the right age to give your kid a cell phone?
When Roseann Styczynski tells people her son got his first cell phone at age six, she’s prepared for the “Are you crazy?” look.
But while a 2007 poll by MSN/Zogby found that 47% of adults believed children should be in high school before owning a cell phone, parents are apparently talking outside of two sides of their mouth. A more recent survey in the U.K. pegged the average age of first-time cell phone owners at eight. Plenty of parents out there are buying phones for very little kids.
Styczynski says her job at Verizon had nothing to do with her decision to buy her then-six-year-old, Matthew, the (since discontinued) Migo, a mobile made for kids that would allow them to dial only four numbers plus 911. There was no voice mail, no texting, and GPS came standard.
“We were at a birthday party at one of those giant party places and while I was chatting with another mom, my son ran into the men’s room to go to the bathroom,” Styczynski explains. “When I noticed that he wasn’t there, with the assistance of a few other moms I scoured the place and finally found him. He was gone for about five minutes, but it was the longest five minutes of my life.”
The next day, she bought the phone.
“I do get that look, that ‘You got your kid a cell phone?’ look. But when I tell them my story, they say, ‘Oh’,” the Saratoga Springs, New York, mom says. A second passes while it clicks. “Then they say, ‘Oh, does Verizon still have that phone?’”
Many parents would be hard-pressed to find fault with Styczyinski’s reasoning. We’ve all been at that giant fun-center with what sounds like a thousand screaming first graders and a man dressed like a mouse riling them up.
It’s why Daniel Neal created Kajeet, a phone company that bills itself as “the cell phone service made 4 kids.” The number one request from parents is the GPS phone finder, he says, a feature the father of two preteens made available from the get-go. Founded by a group of fathers, Kajeet was a company formed to fill what seemed to be a niche market – cell phones with family-specific services. It’s working. The company incorporated in 2003, and has been making deals with the likes of Turner Broadcasting and Amazon to bring their phones and services to the masses.
And no wonder – a recent U.S. Cellular survey estimated 60% of teens have cell phones. According to market research from the Yankee Group, 54% of eight- to twelve-year-olds will have cell phones within the next three years. You don’t even have to go to a phone company to get one – today the Firefly is available right at your local toy store.
“If you’ve seen a teen today or a preteen, you’ll notice that their cell phones are almost tethered to them,” says psychologist Dr. Jerry Weichman, PhD., author of How to Deal. Every patient in his busy Newport Beach, California, adolescent practice walks in with a cell phone.
Weichman isn’t a critic of cell phones or even of kids with cell phones. He is, however, a critic of parents who don’t put their foot down.
“A cell phone has to come with a lot of rules and regulations,” he says. “They need to start off with clearly defined rules – no forbidden sites, no naked pictures, no explicit texts.”
The problem of kids taking naked pictures and sending them out via cell phone, commonly known as sexting, is not just media hype, Weichman says. “I’ve seen girls as young as eleven sending naked pictures and being caught. The boys are relentless as far as trying to get the pictures.”
The stories of kids sending out thousands of texts in one month aren’t hype either. Peter Robertson of Ohio found that out the first month after he and his wife finally broke down and bought their thirteen-and-a-half-year-old daughter a cell phone.
“We resisted a long time, but our target date kept eroding,” Robertson says. “Originally it was when she got her driver’s license. Then it was when she entered high school. Then it became halfway through eighth grade.”
In her first month, their daughter sent 1,200 texts.
Fortunately, the Robertsons had an unlimited text messaging plan. They also had a lot of rules in place: “She has to pay any overages from voice minutes. It can’t stay overnight with her in her room. She has to have it put away and silenced during family time, meals, etc.,” Robertson explains. “Car rides with her are a little fuzzier, but her father is a bit of a Crackberry addict himself, so this struggle to define its role in her life has helped me reflect on my own!”
Adults’ dependence on cell phones plays a major role in the increased dependence children have on them, says Dr. Susan Linn, director of the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood and a psychologist at Harvard Medical School.
“They market it to parents as a safety device, and they market it to kids as being cool,” Linn says. She’s of the mind that children do not need cell phones until at least the teen years; that’s when her teenager got her first phone.
“There are very few times that younger children are away from adults,” Linn says. “Parents say they need them in case they’re running late to pick up their child from soccer practice, but if any coach abandoned a child on a soccer field, that would be the end of a coach’s career.”
Wireless companies are preying on America’s “culture of fear.”Linn thinks wireless companies are preying on America’s “culture of fear.” Her proof? The same GPS system used by parents to track their kids is being used by companies who are marketing to kids via text message. Such companies constantly call for kids to text in their votes (think American Idol) or to sign up for giveaways and encouraging them to make “free” downloads. Once the companies have the kids’ phone numbers, they’re fair game.
Which comes back to the rules and regulations – and taking a long hard look at why you’re getting your child a cell phone. Parents buy cell phones for their kids, technically, but we’re also buying the cell phones for us.
“Non-traditional parenting calls for technology,” Kajeet’s Neal says. “Think about a single mom out there working two jobs. She doesn’t love her child any less than a two-parent household. But she needs logistical support, and phones are just that.”
They help two-parent families too. Jay Hemmaday of Portland, Oregon activated an old handset on his family plan for $10 a month when his daughter was eleven, just after moving back to the Portland area. With new friends, a new school and so many changes, it was meant to be an emergency phone, to reach Jay and his wife. The Hemmadys now both work out of the house, and they call it their “peace of mind.”
“We want her to continue to build up her independence, to not have mom or dad around all the time, yet [to feel] safe and confident that we can be quickly reached,” he notes. “We wanted her to gain the confidence of owning something important. We wanted her to learn to become more responsible and not feel like she was not being trusted, as she was indeed growing up and becoming more responsible with other things.”
Wireless technology is part of the twenty-first century, and cell phones aren’t going away. As parents, we have to figure out how they work in their lives – or don’t. But we have to take control.
“As far as when to get a cell phone, to me it’s not an age as much as it is a maturity level,” Weichman explains.
As Robertson reminds his daughter, “We bought this cell phone and laptop, so we own them. I am very clear that it is within my rights to read anything on either device. And we have her passwords.”








I’m more worried about the cancer causing electromagnetic energy effecting my child’s growth from carrying a cell phone than my own 5 minutes of panic by not knowing where he is at a birthday party. Although life would seem safer and happier, if not cooler or hipper, if we all carried cell phones, I conclude that good health overrides all luxuries and that it’s just specious thinking to see otherwise.
Where in the world would a 6 year old be that a responsible parent couldn’t find them? In the case of the mother who didn’t know her son went in to the bathroom at a big play center, well, you obviously weren’t paying attention to your child’s whereabouts. It happens, but you found him right???. I’m not about to GPS my child because I’m too lazy to keep an eye on him/her. Parents are always fearing the worst these days. My friends and I would ride our bikes several blocks from home at 8 and 9 years old and guess what? We always came back when we heard our parents yelling for us. That was old school GPS.
I rarely use my cellphone and so I don’t want my child being dependent on it to overcommunicate with their friends. If they need a ride home, there’s always that wonderful invention…the pay phone. Or better yet, go into the school office and ask to use the phone if your mom forgot to pick you up.
I’m sure when my children are teenagers and our lives are more separated, I can see the benefit of a cell phone ( especially with GPS). I just don’t get parents who think there is any need for their kids to text their friends all day and all night. Seems that it’s a big time waster. What do they need to say via text that they can’t say over the phone or in person? Couldn’t they being doing something more productive? I think some parents should try and remember that when we were teenagers, none of this stuff existed and we all lived and became productive adults. Technology is great but it has it’s time and place.
This is not something I have had to think about yet, as my son is too young. However, I’m sure each family’s needs are different. Sometimes I think people are against something just because it is a new technology. The whole “we didn’t have this when we were kids” does not seem like a good reason not to have one. There were plenty of things we had as kids that our parents did not.If a phone can have the option not to allow texts and to only call certain numbers, I don’t see the big issue. I think we will probably know when the time is right, but I don’t want to have a pre-set restriction in my head right now.
My wife’s cousin who is 12 (about to turn 13) got her first BlackBerry
over the weekend. What does a teenager need with a BlackBerry. Made
it is me, but I long for the simple days.
tipytop, you should also be worried about the seven horsemen of the apocalypse riding off with your child, too
Good luck trying to find a pay phone in LA. The phone companies have removed most of them to force customers to buy cel phones.
NoHo Mom, I was going to say the same thing about pay phones. We live in San Francisco, and I can’t think of where I could find a pay phone if I needed it. I can remember some a few years ago, but they were magnets for drug dealers and all got ripped out.
Has no one seen the stats on how much radiation is emitted from cell phones? I don’t even allow a cell phone within 3 feet of my baby girl! I know it’s a little paranoid but we just don’t know the long term affects on having these devices so close to the brain of a 6 year old…..
You don’t need a cell phone to give you peace of mind as to the whereabouts and safety of a six year old; you should know where they are and who they are with when they are not with you. Frankly my mind boggles at the number of parents who seem happy to let their kids roam the streets unsupervised for hours on end. I think the potential risks they would be exposed to through owning a phone are much greater than any dangers they would encounter if you’re 5 minutes late picking them up.
Older children and teenagers may want a cell to keep in touch with friends and I think in this day and age it’s hypocritical of parents who rely heavily on their mobile phones to expect their kids not to want one. But if you’re buying your child a cell phone to plug the gaps in your parenting then don’t be surprised if it comes back to bite you…
mumunplugged said – “Frankly my mind boggles at the number of parents who seem happy to let their kids roam the streets unsupervised for hours on end.”This comment baffles me, because what I hear over and over again is the criticism that there are too many “helicopter parents”, and kids these days are constantly supervised, never allowed to roam around, don’t experience the freedom “we” had, etc. etc. I don’t have a strong opinion either way, but this just goes to show that parents can never win. We don’t know what goes on in every family, so we can’t say what is best for everyone. I do have to say, to those who are worried about the radiation from cell phones, I wouldn’t imagine that young children would be on the phone for hours on end. Instead, the phone could be programmed to only call mom/dad for emergencies.
who cares, it’s just a phone. if you can afford it for your kid, go for it. if not, oh well. i would never look @ some1 elses kid that has a phone and think “wow, that parents lazy” how dumb is that? maybe i’m from another generation, but in my mind a cell phone is the same as any other run of the mill electronic device.
Tipytop and Monkey…coming from someone who unfortunately has brain cancer…the thought of what a cell phone can do to a developing brain is frightening. I would never allow my child to have a cell phone because despite what many people think, most likely there is a connection between brain cancer/tumors and cell phones. Just wait 10 years and I think we will be shocked to think that we ever allowed children to have cell phones…
Our daughter is only 5 but she carries around a deactivated cell phone so she can be like us (and neither my husband nor I are on the phone much at all–we never use our allotted minutes). She won’t have a real one until she’s 16 and driving–And if she really needs to call us, she can borrow a friend’s phone. See how that works? I don’t care if all her other friends get one at 10 or 12 or whatever: what other parents do is not my concern. Pop culture does not drive my decision making, and that’s pretty much all there is to it.
We don’t even have a land line so how would we expect our kid to be in touch with friends if they don’t have a phone? I know I don’t want to take their friends’ calls. I remember a similar debate when I was a kid – whether or not we could have our own line. I kind of have to take the “a phone is a phone” tack. I remember being on the phone a lot as a girl and nowadays – at least for us – cell phones are our only phones. So we’ll just have to impose limits like we would with a land line.
NoHo mom and calimom — I hear ya on the scarcity of pay phones!
At the same time, I also figure that since so many people HAVE cell phones these days, there is always a phone nearby. What’s wrong with asking someone to use theirs? I’ve done this at least a couple times and haven’t yet had anyone tell me that their minutes were too precious for the likes of me or anything like that. As silly as it might sound, I think that there is actual value in being forced to rely on others in an emergency and on branching out of one’s social shell enough to ask a favor of a stranger.
I have a problem with people who don’t have cell phones asking to borrow mine. If you have made the decision that you do not want a cell phone because it’s 1) going to give you brain cancer or 2) way too mainstream for someone as cool as you, then why should I let you use mine? I have a friend who is contantly telling anyone who will listen, in a smug, self-satisfied way, that she doesn’t own a cell phone. But the second she can’t track down her husband, she’s asking to borrow my cell.
If you want your kid to be able to call you when he/she is going to be late, then give the kid a phone. Do not have him/her ask my kid for a phone. Cell phones have saved my bacon more than a few times, so I’m keeping mine and when my daughter reaches middle school she will get her own….and no, you can’t borrow it.
Honestly, I think that as a parent, it’s so important to keep track of your kids this day in age and know exactly where they are at all times. I mean seriously, we don’t like in the 50s anymore where society was much safer than it is now. I gave both my kids the Motorola W376 phone from Tracfone especially because it has a camera which my kids can take photos as proof to show me where they are. It also has great games for them to play when they are bored and it comes with the “Double Minutes” feature which means we get one minute free for every minute you buy. This phone is super cheap, too, because it costs less than $30.
Ummmm….seriously?
“I gave both my kids the Motorola W376 phone from Tracfone especially because it has a camera which my kids can take photos as proof to show me where they are”
Unless you’ve had chronic problems with your children lying about where they are, givng your kids a camera phone to they can prove in photos where they are or have been is… words fail…. overprotective? insulting to the kids (we can’t trust you at all!)? The only way to get honesty is to give trust, at least that’s how I feel.
Having said that, I don’t want to tell anyone their parenting is wrong….I just would have been hurt if my parents had had so little faith in me (& then I would have proceeded to show them how untrustworthy I could be….after all they’d already decided I was dishonest & sneaky…I’m definately not perfect!).
Parents,
Please check out this info on safe cell phone use for all ages:
http://environmentalhealthtrust.org/node/203
It’s all about keeping our families healthy.
Peace
Six is a bit young, I have to agree. But we use prepaid phones for both our teens. We certainly do not encourage (or pay for) high usage on the phones but we really want to enable them to be able to dial 911 or get hold of us anytime from anywhere. The Tracfones we use are ideal because they have great coverage and are quite reliable. We only buy a limited number of minutes and they have to make them last through the month. That way they are able to stay in touch without racking up huge bills. More than once it has proven to be a great tool to let us know of sudden changes to schedules or pick-up times etc.
I don’t have a specific age in mind but it will be when they are in middle school at least. My thing is when they do get it they will not have texting, phone, web if I can’t find a phone without it than they won’t get a phone. Teens even good ones say and do stupid things and if you text or sext someone it can wind up anywhere. If you do something dumb like flash a guy in person he might tell and you might get a little embarassed if you do it in a sext it might wind up on every phone in the class and facebook.
Me and my three year old daughter could really use something like the Migo. She has to go visit her father in Colorado for months at a time. We’re states away and because our marriage ended on bad terms, he never lets her call home. Having her own cellphone to call mom whenever she needs to would really help her with the distance. There are situations that warrant a small child to have a cellphone.
Since the Migo has been discontinued, there are other options such as the iBaby:
http://www.wholesale-in-china.org/wholesale/Children+mobile+phone.html
I found just what I was ndeeed, and it was entertaining!
I don’t have an opinion I just know what we do and why. No one gets a cellphone unless they can pay for the monthly minutes. Even our oldest daughter who graduated college in 2005 didn’t have one until she got one for herself after she started working. Her professors were amazed that she didn’t have one, but she didn’t really want nor need one. I guess every family is different. I just figure if you can’t afford it yourself you can’t have one.