Multi-Faith Christmas Traditions | Multi-Faith Hanukkah Traditions | Multi-Faith Holidays

Holiday Gift Overload

How to keep the fun in holiday traditions.

by Rebecca Odes & Ceridwen Morris

December 16, 2009



My husband is Jewish and I’m Catholic so we have a lot of holiday celebrations at our house. The celebrating part is great, but the piles of gifts for the kids is ridiculous. I’m sure my husband (although he hasn’t said it) doesn’t want us diminishing Hanukkah excitement for kiddos too young by not giving the kids small gifts each night. And I was raised with the belief that a pile of gifts under the tree and a full stocking is the best part of the season – but enough is enough. Eight nights of gifts followed by a visit from Santa (not to mention, two sets of Grandparents) has us drowning in toys/clothes/socks. How can we stop the madness without taking the presents out of one celebration or the other?

We Need More Closets!

Dear Closets,

If you want less merchandise in the house, you and your husband are going to need to make some edits to your respective nostalgic expectations. You’ll have to give up the idea that Christmas is only Christmas when Santa’s generosity overflows to the front door. And your husband will have to give up the idea that Hanukkah is an eight-day marathon of continuous excitement. But you can build traditions and associations that work better for your new family.

You both know you want to dial down. Now you just have to hash out the details of your hybrid holiday plan. A good place to start is by sitting down with your husband and working out what’s important to each of you about your holiday memories. What do you think you’d miss most? What’s most special, and what might be redundant? Are there broader family plans and traditions you need to take into account?

You could do one big night of Hanukkah and a smaller Christmas. You could focus on the family gatherings and have smaller things on your own. You could give eight nights of sweets then toys on Christmas, or vice versa. Some people give basic necessities snow boots and pillowcases to make the whole affair more practical. There are lots of solutions. You get to create your own, personal, meaningful, crazy, funny, touching, mixed-up, unforgettable tradition. However you slice and dice, it makes sense to consider some kind of gift giving on both holidays so as not to skew the balance in your kids’ eyes.

If you and your husband are having any trouble reconciling what to keep and what to toss, keep in mind that this will be an evolving process. You can see how the first year goes and tweak accordingly. If you find yourself missing the morning bounty, or your husband goes to bed with a sad feeling because you’ve ixnayed the Hanukah gelt, you can always reintroduce it next year.

Have a question? Email

Find more:

This article was written by Rebecca Odes and Ceridwen Morris for, the magazine and community for a new generation of parents.


Click to buy Ceridwen and Rebecca’s book!

Article Posted 7 years Ago

Videos You May Like