When I Do Becomes I Dont: 5 Signs You Should Break Off Your Engagement

Six months before her wedding, twenty-four-year-old Melissa Smith* had it all: an enviable job as Director of Sales for a popular hotel chain, love with her college sweetheart-turned-fiancé Barry, and preparations for the wedding of her dreams.

Until the day her horse, a gift from her fiancé, fell ill. She took the horse to the local veterinarian and later that night, called her best friend with some startling news.

“I think I’m in love with my veterinarian,” she announced.

“I had everything set for the wedding,” Melissa recalls. “The dress, the invitations, the bridesmaids. Everything. But when I met him, I was in awe.”

Melissa found Dr. Goodall*, a veterinarian and horse surgeon, to be handsome and witty. “He was a lot of fun,” Melissa relates. “And I was completely in love with what he did for a living.”

The next day, as she drove to her final dress fitting, Melissa’s thoughts wandered back to the doctor.

“I found myself thinking, ‘Well, if the marriage doesn’t work out, I can always get a divorce,'” Melissa remembers, shaking her blonde hair slightly. With that thought, Melissa immediately slammed on her brakes in the middle of the interstate.

“I knew right then,” said Melissa. “I couldn’t go through with it.”

Although official records on broken engagements are not kept, according to a 2003 article in Time magazine, an estimated 20 to 25 percent of engagements are broken each year in the United States. We have all heard of the pre-wedding jitters. But the decision to call off a wedding involves more than just cold feet. It’s the decision of a lifetime.

So just how do you know if a relationship isn’t right? How can you know if “the one” is the one that needs to go?


Photo credit: J & J Brusie Photography (located in Florida) 

  • You Just Know 1 of 7

    Many women who have broken off engagements describe a "gut feeling" or an instinct that the man was not right for them from the beginning — but that they simply got too far in the relationship to feel like they could break things off.

    "I think I always knew that I should not be marrying him," explained one woman who has broken off a previous engagement in the past and wishes to remain anonymous. "But I was waiting for a moment that was bad enough that I could justify to myself that I was doing the right thing by calling it off."

    Photo credit: Flickr/ekkiPics

  • You Look for Excuses to Avoid Him 2 of 7

    I found myself searching for jobs that took me away from where the town we lived in," explained Sarah*. "I knew then I really wanted out of the relationship if I wanted a job the kept me from seeing him." 

    Photo credit: Flickr/Pink Sherbert Photography

  • You Avoid Making Wedding Plans 3 of 7

    "I had made sure of that in the planning that nothing was hard to return, like my dress," Sarah confessed. "In all the days leading up to the marriage, I was very scared and didn't really want to make any plans. 

    Photo credit: Flickr/Salicia

  • You Fight All of the Time 4 of 7

    The engagement time is a relatively carefree and happy time in a couples' relationship. And although that's not to say that wedding planning isn't stressful (it is!) or that happy couples don't fight (they do!), if you are fighting more often than not, something may be off. As Sarah noticed, "I didn't want to sell my condo in case I needed a place to go to when we fought…there were so many signs…"

    Photo credit: Flickr/Ed Yourdun

  • He Threatens to Call the Police on You 5 of 7

    Sure, it may sound like a no-brainer, but women trapped in physically or verbally abusive relationships, behavior that might have once seemed crazy can start to feel "normal" over time. For Sarah, after a bad fight that left her "bawling for the 1,000th time," it took her fiancé threatening to call the police on her to serve as her wake-up call. "I knew it was far past over then," she says. "I told him I would mail the ring." 

    Photo credit: Flickr/connor395

  • It Will Be OK… 6 of 7

    For women like Sarah, who is now happily planning a wedding to man who helped her see that "love could be so perfect and easy" or Melissa who went on to became the doctor's wife, enjoying over eleven years of marriage and the addition of two beautiful daughters, the decision to break off an engagement isn't a complicated one.

    It was about putting their happiness first.

    "It was the right decision," says Melissa simply.


     Photo credit: J & J Brusie Photography (located in Florida)

    *Names have been changed to protect privacy

  • Read more 7 of 7

    Read more of Chaunie's posts here or learn more about Chaunie (and her husband) by checking out her blog and following along on Facebook!

    Recent posts by Chaunie:

    Could Antidepressants Be Ruining Your Love Life?

    What He's Really Thinking 

    Could You Be Duped By Online Dating? One Woman's "Catfished" Tale

    13 Fun + Easy Ways to Say "I Love You"


Article Posted 3 years Ago
share this article
facebook twitter tumblr pinterest
See Comments
what do you think?
share this article
facebook twitter tumblr pinterest
See Comments
what do you think?
what do you think?
close comments

Videos You May Like